Posted on January 18th, 2017 No comments
The last test has been completed, and I’d say the cooling fan hack is a success!
Climbing the Eiffel Tower
One of the earlier prints I did with the 101Hero was a series of Eiffel Tower models, from Thingiverse. There were tower models I liked better, but this one seemed simple and within the ability of the 101Hero 3D printer.
They were generally good for the first 30 mm, but after that degenerated into a twisted, molten mess. The diagnosis was excessive heat.
- The first treatment, reduced print temperature, was not much better.
- The second treatment a 2″ (40 cm) fan beside the print bed to provide cooling, was more successful. The print was reasonably good to 50 mm, with less twisting and globbing in the upper tower.
- The third treatment, using a “cooling tower” to print beside the model, was less successful. Excessive stringing made one corner of the Eiffel tower a mess, and in all was not as good as the previous print.
Adding the Head-Mounted Cooling Fan
The final test of this project was to print an identical tower using only the head-mounted fan for cooling. I scaled the height of the model to 75 mm, which was the measured height of the earlier series. However, I did not duplicate the settings of those earlier models (I have learned a few things since then). Being a bit impatient, I set layer height to 0.2 mm to reduce print time (this also seems to have resulted in the model being 80 mm tall). I used support touching the buildplate, and a raft, because some of those earlier towers had lost a leg and suffered other detachment errors.
The print went almost perfectly to about 65 mm. At that point, the behaviour of the head changed, and instead of printing a bit and waiting, it began running continuously. I could actually see the head dragging the molten plastic in a small circle. Five millimeters later, the head went back to printing a side, waiting, printing a side, waiting…. This seems almost to be a setting error, one I might be able to track down in the gCode.
Test Results shown above: Left, head-mount fan; center, bed-mount fan (red feet tell you it was done right after the set done in red 101PLA); right, cooling tower. Dang, it’s in sharp focus on my computer, even zoomed in. Why is it soft-focus here?
Woohoo! The head-mounted fan created the best-looking print. We’ll call this a success!
But this isn’t the end. Ideas for the future:
- I might want to extend the duct to move the vent about 1 mm closer to the extruder nozzle.
- Another possibility is to add a ring-shaped vent to surround the nozzle. However, my first attempts at this failed, since this project was done at about the limits of accuracy for the 101 Hero. Doesn’t mean it can’t be done. Just means I couldn’t do it a few weeks ago.
- I might wait until my next printer comes, and print another fan system in ABS
- The little rotary fan really doesn’t move much air (1.2 litres per minute). If I can find a small centrifugal “squirrel cage” fan it might improve the cooling.
- I’d like to experiment with an aquarium blower, which pipes air through a tube. I’m thinking a 1/8″ metal ring around the nozzle, with holes drilled for the vents.
Lots of fun still to come.
Posted on January 17th, 2017 No comments
Earlier, I wrote about experiments I did with building a head-mounted cooling fan for the 101Hero. It’s in place and running now, so it’s time to finish writing up the project.
I use HVAC (Heating, Ventilating, Air Conditioning) terminology here. The plenum is the upper part, which contains the fan, and gathers and directs blown air into the duct. This is the narrower tube that guides the air to its destination. The vent is the aperture or opening at the end of the duct that directs air forward and down around the print nozzle. These parts can perhaps more clearly be seen in the earlier article.
Making it Airtight
Because I had printed this to be lightweight, I used a print height of 0.1 mm, with side/top/bottom layers of 0.8 mm (along with a slow print speed, very light support, and 20% infill overlap). The result was that the plenum (the part that holds the fan) and duct (which leads the air around to the nozzle) were basically a mesh that leaked air everywhere. I tested this by blocking the vent with my finger and blowing into the plenum.
The inside surfaces were a bit rough, and I wondered about mixing white glue and water and pouring it inside to smooth the surface and improve airflow, but the thing is just so dang small! I was afraid the glue would block off the duct. The best I could do was cut a little strip of sandpaper to run back and forth inside the duct, and scrape the inside of the plenum with the square end of a small file. After cleanup, tThe two parts fit well together; I glued them with CA glue.
Then I mixed up some five-minute epoxy (JB Weld brand) and carefully smeared it all over the outside of the assembled fan unit. I used this epoxy because it is both heat resistant and fireproof. It took two coats to completely seal all the leaks. So much for light weight! It might have been better to print a sturdier part in the first place! Or maybe use spray paint… Then I sanded it a bit, especially the top of the duct that had to rest against the bottom of the print head. I might have to sand more for a better fit.
The fan dropped nicely into its bracket atop the plenum, but there was still a little air leakage around the fan frame, so I roughly sealed it with transparent tape for the trial runs. I also snipped off the tiny electrical connector and soldered on a two-pin job to hook up to the 5V power supply unit (PSU) that had been running my LEDs and print-bed fan. While I’m using the head-mounted fan, I’ll have no lights, and the little head-mount unit will be the only cooling fan.
With the fan running, there’s a reasonable amount of air coming out, directed at the recently laid layer, about 3 mm back of the nozzle. This was about where I’d wanted it.
Since I had 101Hero gold filament in the printer and wanted to print some gold vases, that was where I started. The purpose of these tests was to determine if
- the duct would clear the print
- not interfere in any way with the print process
- provide reasonable cooling
There was no off-switch in the experimental setup, so I unplugged the PSU for the first three (bottom) layers. Once the walls of the vase (50 mm diameter, 95 mm high) started to print, I plugged in the PSU and left the print to run. No issues, and fewer hairs than usual, despite the number of times the head criss-crosses the diameter of the vase (I don’t know why it can’t just go around the outside, but it doesn’t, it does part of a wall, then crosses over and does part of a wall on the other side, then comes back and does more on this side….)
Success So Far
The duct is narrow enough that it clears the print, and did not in any way interfere with the process. The print result was as good as those done with the more powerful 40 mm bed-mounted fan. There were a couple of holes in the side walls. This had also happened even worse with the BotFeeder translucent white, but not with the RepRap silver. I think this is just a difference in filament quality.
The second vase in the series was printed oval, 60 mm x 80 mm x 50 mm high. The extra width was to see if the suspension arms would hit the fan unit (they didn’t) and the reduced height was just to make sure I didn’t run out of filament and to keep the print time down. This print showed considerable stringing and gobbing, suggesting that the cooling was not sufficient.
The Next Series of Tests
There was no heat damage to the vent area, so I might re-position the duct closer to the nozzle. I’ll also better seal the fan housing into the plenum so that all air blown by the fan goes down the duct and out the vent.
The real test, of course, will be something tall and spindly like an Eiffel Tower, or a good test print like a Benchy. I’ll run those tomorrow using the silver RepRap PLA.
Posted on January 17th, 2017 No comments
I’ve signed up for the 2017 Johnson MS Bike, Leduc to Camrose. This will be my second participation in this 160 km event, and I’m looking forward to it. (Circumstances prevented my riding in 2015 and 2016. This year I just said “circumstances be danged — I’m gonna ride!”).
Several of my friends have been diagnosed with MS — the disease is surprisingly common in Canada. In fact, Canada has the highest rate of multiple sclerosis in the world (Did you know that you are 13 times more likely to develops MS here than in Argentina, for example?) The highest rate in the world — and as yet, no one knows why.
But we’ll find out why. We are also home to some of the best MS research in the world, thanks to the support of folks like you. MS research has changed people’s lives, and researchers are working hard to find a cure for the disease.
I’ll be riding to raise money to help my friends and every other Canadian living with MS. Proceeds raised fund both world-class research and innovative programs and services across Canada. By supporting me in MS Bike, you make this research possible.
Every little bit helps in the search for a cure, and you can help #endMS by donating.
About Multiple Sclerosis
MS is currently classified as an autoimmune disease of the central nervous system (brain, spinal cord). The disease attacks myelin, the protective covering of the nerves, causing inflammation and often damaging the myelin. Myelin is necessary for the transmission of nerve impulses through nerve fibres. If damage to myelin is slight, nerve impulses travel with minor interruptions; however, if damage is substantial and if scar tissue replaces the myelin, nerve impulses may be completely disrupted, and the nerve fibres themselves can be damaged.
MS is unpredictable and can cause symptoms such as extreme fatigue, lack of coordination, weakness, tingling, impaired sensation, vision problems, bladder problems, cognitive impairment and mood changes. Its effects can be physical, emotional and financial. Currently there is no cure, but each day researchers are learning more about what causes MS and are zeroing in on ways to prevent it.
About the MS Bike Route
The MS Bike series is the largest event of its kind in North America, and the Leduc-Camrose ride is the largest in Canada. There are many rides, and some cyclists participate in more than one ride.
- Leduc to Camrose and Return
- Route Length(s): Approx. 80km/day
- Early Check-in Date: June 5 & 6 & 9 | June 7 & 8
- Early Check-in Time: 9 am – 6 pm | 9 am – 8 pm
- Ride Dates: June 10-11, 2017
- Start Time: 07:30
About Fundraising Goals
The Leduc-Camrose run is apparently the largest event of its kind in Canada. Last year, some 3000 cyclists and teams collectively raised over $2,000,000. We hope to match or better that this year. We know times are tough for a lot of folks in Alberta these days, but things are even tougher when you have a debilitating disease like MS.
Every cyclist will be riding to contribute to the overall goal. My personal goal is $2000. That’s a tiny fraction of the total , but every bit helps. If I have to talk to 200 people to get $10 each, that’s fine (a few at $50 and $100 is even finer, of course). All I ask is that you give whatever you feel you can spare to help out.
I’m just getting started and have already reached 5% of my goal! With your help, I’ll get there. With our help comes help for MS sufferers.
How to Contribute
You can donate online by going to my Participant Center and clicking “Donate Now”.
Posted on January 9th, 2017 No commentsWhen I mounted the control box to a pylon, I moved the factory LED to the other side so it would be visible from where I sit. Since then, I’ve been annoyed that this LED is also on when the USB cable is plugged in, so I can’t easily tell at a glance if I’ve remembered to turn off the printer. I have to come up and check the switch, what a chore! Or unplug the USB cable, even worse!
Adding a Power LED – First TryI figured the factory LED was run off 5V — there are two 7805 voltage regulators on the board and the LED appears to come right off one of them — and that I could just put another LED across 12V off the power switch to ground. And that worked fine — turn on the switch and the new LED lights up. There’s my power-on/off indicator.
To my surprise and annoyance, that LED also lights when just the USB cable is plugged in — just like the existing LED.I would have thought the 12V power supply would be totally separate from the 5V USB and UART. As far as I can tell (can hardly see the traces, let alone track them), there’s only a 1000u cap across the inputs before the voltage regulators.
Second Try — Using 5V from the USB CableThe USB jack also has 5V at pin 4 supplied by the hero board, rather than from the computer. So much for an indicator across pins 1 and 4 there. It’s always on when the power’s on. It’s always on when the USB cable is connected. It’s the same as the existing factory LED.
A Standby Indicator LEDFor now, I’ve put a small green LED from ground to the unused third pin of the switch. It glows when the printer is OFF, a kind of “safe” or “standby” light. It’s drilled through the top of the case and is readily visible. I used a 470 ohm resistor but in retrospect a 1K resistor would have been fine — the LED doesn’t have to light up my office at night.
Posted on January 9th, 2017 No comments
In one video I watched recently, the presenter (I think it might have been Angus Deveson, Maker’s Muse) commented that some 3d printers are toys while others are tools. The first kind are hobby machines for playing around with, good for making nick-nacks and gizmos and toys, while others are are more work machines, good for creating useful objects, prototypes, and replacement parts.
101Hero: Toy or Tool?My 101Hero is an improvement over its predecessor, the Makerbot Cupcake. Still, the 101Hero, like most other inexpensive definitely falls into the toy category. Perhaps more than some, the 101Hero suffers limitations that fix it more firmly as toy than tool:
- structural considerations
- quality control
- speed limitations
- size limitations
- printing limitations
Structural ConsiderationsTools are made of metal, toys are made of plastic. The 101Hero is injection-molded. The plastic pylons have some triangular reinforcement and are reasonably stiff. The plastic base and top are not; they flex. The machine is ok if you don’t disturb it at all, but don’t move it or even bang the desk or table while it’s printing. Doing so will guarantee skipped or offset layers. Even a heavy tread on the floor can be enough to disrupt a print.
Poor Quality ControlBeyond the usual late delivery and poor communications characteristic of struggling crowd-funded products, 101Hero seems to suffer an inordinate number of QC issues. Shipping seems to be slowly catching up, with the colored models finally reaching backers. However, the official web page and official Facebook page contain no news for backers at the time I write this.Users report missing parts, incorrect colors, doa controllers, defective stepper motors, broken gears, warped or loose slide rods. In an “Unofficial” Facebook post dated Dec 8, one user stated “I was just successful in requesting a refund from indiegogo. They canceled my backing since it had not shipped yet. They said in an email they are overwhelmed with a flood of complaints of broken units, wrong units shipped and no customer service to back the product
The creator has publicly stated that delivery is their main priority, which puts customer relations a distant second. While this may be short-sighted, it does show some determination to get the product (whether it works or not) out to backers. Probably their thinking is that once the headaches of delivery are gone, they may have time and energy to devote to customer service.
Delta (three-sided) printers are supposed to have advantages of speed. Where even a mid-level printer will print at 50 mm/s or more, the Hero has a top speed of 14 mm/s, with reasonably good printing coming at 10-12 mm/s. Many users have reduced the speed to as low as 5 mm/s in an attempt at better quality. In consequence, print times of eight hours or more are common. The 101Hero, if designed to be used by children, will definitely teach them patience.
; Build Summary for 352 Elephant ; Build time: 8 hours 2 minutes ; Filament length: 9340.8 mm (9.34 m) ; Plastic volume: 22467.20 mm^3 (22.47 cc) ; Plastic weight: 28.08 g (0.06 lb) ; Material cost: 1.29
Uneven Printing Across the Print Bed: Size Limitations
Wide prints simply do not work, because the printer cannot follow a straight flat line from one side of the print bed to the other: it arcs or rises over the center. Hannes Brandstätter-Müller of Austria posted on the 101Hero Unofficial Facebook page: “I encounter the same lifting in the center when doing wide movements. It’s annoying…”
An adjustment that lays a good first layer in the center 50 mm will drive the nozzle into the print bed at the perimeter. An adjustment good at the perimeter will not attach in the center. My first thought on noticing this was that somehow the glass print bed had warped, an unlikely notion quickly dismissed by checking with a steel straightedge.
This inability to do a wide print appears to be a weakness or flaw of the firmware that effectively limits the print diameter to at most 80 mm (roughly half of the 150 mm build plate). The only workaround is to modify the print file — divide it into two smaller parts that can be printed in the center.It appears that the creator-supplied models will fit within this small central diameter and provide reasonable results. It’s only user-created parts or wide parts imported from other sources that will be problematic.
ConclusionIf you want a sturdy machine that will work out of the box, get something else. The 101Hero is an inexpensive toy for printing toys. It falls into that class of 3D printers that is to play with, not to work with. It’s a machine for those who are prepared to tinker, fiddle, diddle, and hack.
Posted on January 6th, 2017 1 comment
One weakness of the 101Hero 3d Printer is the lack of a cooling fan. Most users have compensated for this with bed-mounted fans. But wouldn’t it be neat to add a cooling fan to the head, to direct cooling air right onto the recently-printed layer, just like on a more expensive printer?
Where to Mount the Fan
There are two likely places for such a fan:
- In “front”, under the filament access door.
- At “back”, under the hump of the stepper motor
I thought the front location might interfere with access to changing filaments, and the shape of the duct would be difficult due to the need to fit in the yoke between the struts. I also briefly considered mounting a fan on the top, beside the wiring and the filament tube, but thought that would be awkward. Because of that I chose the “back” position.
Choosing a Fan
In either location, there isn’t much room. At the front, there might be space for a 20 mm fan, while at the back, the most likely size is 15 mm. I got a tiny 15 mm fan on Ebay for $10 plus $7 shipping, and found a 20 mm fan at Aliexpress for $10 with shipping included.
The little 5V fan came within two weeks from Las Vegas. It pumps 12 litres/minute at 15.7kPa, a fraction of the amount from the 40 mm fan I have mounted on the print bed. Still, directed through a duct, that small amount of air might be enough to cool the PLA.
Besides, this is just a fun project, intended to help me learn to use 123D Design and to do 3D printing. It is not expected to produce any really practical result.
Developing the Design
I wanted something with minimal curves, with minimal interference with the airflow. I dismounted the head, did some measurements, made some sketches. The first prototype was made of stiff paper from a 2016 calendar, taped together. The idea was that the fan, at the top, could blow down through a duct and the air be directed downwards beside the extruder. I taped the fan into the top, hooked it to a battery, and decided that maybe….
It fit well onto the print head, and it looked like the design might work. Now all I had to do was turn that paper model and my concept into a 3D print using strange software such as TinkerCad and 123Design.
Iteration After Iteration
This part was enjoyable, if a bit tedious. I would figure out make a design (which often involved a lot of Google work), then print it out. Then I had to play with the print settings or the part orientation to get a decent print. Then I’d try it, see what was wrong with it, which also often involved Internet research on “3D printing problems:. Then repeat. And repeat. And repeat.
One obstacle was that I couldn’t really measure or fit with the head mounted in the printer. With the head off to measure and fit, I couldn’t print. Once I put the head back, it often took hours (in one case a full day) to get it readjusted to print properly.
Still, the early printed prototypes snapped securely onto the print head, and were encouraging. Problems with printing led me to cut the part into two, a motor housing and a duct.
So, change this, extend that, find that this didn’t print properly — why not?–move this, try again. I learned about support, orientation, bridging, wall thickness, stringing, retraction. I switched from Cura 15.02 to 15.04 because the latter gave more accurate slicing (in between two Cura versions, I tested KISSlicer, Repetier Host, Craftware, and ICEsl) . I changed setting after setting and kept track of all the changes in a spreadsheet, so that eventually I could identify what worked well and what didn’t. One thing that caused problems was support – Cura insists on putting support inside the duct, which was impossible to get out and which left the inside rough instead of smooth. I wound up using Support “Touching build plate” as it worked the best.
The semi-final version was printed using the best quality I could achieve given my limited knowledge and skills. There may be further modifications to indent the motor housing just under the motor, to allow space for the suspension struts during wide prints.
Anyone interested in duplicating or better yet improving this project will find the files at the 101Hero forum (101user.com).
Is it Safe?
I’m printing in PLA and perhaps having the blower close to the extruder is not a good idea. I am considering sending the part out to be printed commercially, or waiting until I get my Trinus so the duct can be printed in ABS (the blower housing can be PLA). Though, in point of fact, the thing hasn’t melted yet.
In the end, I came up with a design that seems to work as well as it’s going to work. I’ll print another Eiffel Tower to see the result. Does it function and adequately cool the part as it’s printing? Probably not. It seems that 12 L/m of air at 15.7 kPa is not really a lot of movement or pressure. I can feel air coming out the vent, and that’s about as much as I can say for it.
Still, the project taught me a lot about using design software, principles of good design, and some basics of 3D printing. Which was, after all, the main goal.
- Find the files at the 101 User Forum
- 101Hero Hacks, Mods, and Customizations
- Other Kickstarter Printers Coming: Trinus and M3D Pro
Posted on January 3rd, 2017 No comments
Since getting my 101Hero 3D printer, I’ve been watching a lot of how-to videos. Generally speaking, I loathe amateur instructional videos on Youtube. I’m not talking about camera technique, video quality, smoothness of editing or any other technical topic. I’m talking about the person in front of the camera, telling (instead of showing) me something that I want to know or learn or do.
If a video can’t hook me in the first 30 seconds, I’m gone. Lost as an audience now and probably forever.
I used to work in live TV (a show called “Homework Hotline”) . I got that job because as an Advanced Toastmaster, experienced public speaker and award-winning teacher, I was able to present well on air. Not that I didn’t occasionally goof; I’m human. Yes, there was a seven-second delay, and yes, a mistake would be edited in the video for distribution, but when you’re on live transmission, dead air and wasted time are a no-no. A lot of what I’m talking about in this post came from lessons learned on that show.
I’m not going to embarrass anybody by linking to flawed presentations… but ooh, it’s tempting! If you’re a video presenter and you want me (and others) to watch your work, here are five things I wish you’d pay attention to when you do your video.
1. Show some life
Please don’t be just a talking head. Show some animation. If you look and sound bored, the chances are pretty good that your video will be boring. But the chances are also pretty good that I won’t know or care, because I’ll be gone within the first 10 or 15 seconds.
The Hotline hired teachers who could put some pizzazz into a lesson. You need to do that for your video.
2. Get Right Into Your Topic
Our producer used to stress that “Air time is money! Don’t waste it. Get right to your material!” Perhaps as a result of that, I have come to hate presenters who waste a lot of time with long and irrelevant introductions.
“Hi, guys, how ya doin’? This is Greg the curizan specialist comin’ to ya from Upchuck South to tell ya all about how to dilate your curizan. If ya got a curizan that don’t dilate and ya wanna know how to make it do that, I’m the man to tell ya. I picked up my latest curizan at a flea market in Upchuk North for ony a buck, but it didn’t dilate right — ya always gotta be careful with what ya buy in a yard sale, don’t ya? So I had to figure it out and now I’ll share that with you.”
And on, and on, and he’s wasted several minutes telling me NOTHING but what I already knew about the video just from the title. If you’ve picked your title well — “Dilate Your Curizan by Greg”, or “Greg Shows How to Dilate a Curizan” — you needn’t say much more. You don’t even need “Hi, how ya doin’? Greg here again to talk about Curizans.” I know that already.
Save me the trouble of fast-forwarding to where you say something important. Get right into your topic.
3. Have Your Props Ready
For heavens sake, if you need props or samples, have them right at hand. Our floor manager used to rips us a new one if we didn’t have our lesson materials right where we wanted them and right when we needed them.
You’re your own producer and director and floor manager, so this is all under your control. Your items can be off to the side just out of camera range, or on a small table beside you (also out of camera range) or even on the desk in plain sight. Do some preparation, know what you’re going need at each point in your presentation, have your props ready and in sequence.
Above all, please, don’t be dodging off camera to get something. Especially don’t make a comment while you disappear, “Shoot, where did I leave that?” At the very least, edit the break for a smooth transition before posting your video.
4. Don’t Um and Ah.
Speech hesitations, unnecessary interjections, false starts –”Um, man, like, you know, I, uh, got this curizon, and, like, it didn’t work, you know” ARRGH!
You’ll notice that professionals don’t do a lot of this. If you have your own Youtube channel and do a lot of videos, please review a few of your posts and take a count of the number of speech stumbles. If there are more than a couple, plan to do something about it. Take a speech class. Join Toastmasters. Get a friend to slap your face with a dirty sock whenever you do something like this. For Canadians, it’s that unconscious “eh?” at the end of our sentences that we don’t even notice until our American friends tease us about it.
It takes a little practice and training to break these speech habits, but you can learn to speak fluently.
4. Pay Attention to Pacing
This is a toughie that comes with practice. I find that the average video presenter talks so slowly that I want to shake him (or her) and say, “Go! Get on with it!” On the other hand, if you’re rattling along like an auctioneer, I’m going to be missing some of what you say.
Many sources give the average conversational speech rate as about 110 to 140 words a minute, but our listening comprehension goes much higher. Trained professionals — motivational speakers, newscasters, advertising readers–tend to be at the higher end, up to 160 words per minute (one study of Ted Talks found the average rate was 163 wpm). With crisp, clear delivery and good enunciation, a speaker may be understandable at a faster rate, up to around 220 or even 240, but that’s the upper limit for effective listening.
Your goal is somewhere between the used car salesman’s rapid-fire pitch and the kindergarten teacher explaining to the slowest students in the class. Of course, the best speakers also vary their rate, just as they vary their inflection, for greater emphasis on certain points. You can also do this in your video.
But here’s the rub: Average reading speed is 200 to 300 words per minute, and faster readers can easily hit 500 or more. To a reader, your talking video is incredibly, frustratingly, annoyingly s….l….o….w. This is the main reason I hate videos: I can read your material in a fifth of the time it takes you to say it.
5. Don’t Tell Me — Show Me
“Show, don’t tell” is a writer’s dictum that also applies to videos. Most Youtube videos are telling me something (slowly) that I’d rather read (quickly). The value of a video is when you can show me a process or skill or operation that can’t easily be described in words. If you’re just telling, you can video a text screen that I can scroll past after I’ve read it. Saves us both time. But talking heads? Pfui.
I like Instructables because they generally use words and tagged images. I can take those at my pace, as fast as I can handle them. But Instructables also sometimes include short video clips that show or demonstrate some particular point or process. Those are truly worthwhile use of the video format, especially if they’ve been tightly edited to show only the essentials.
Much of what I’ve written here is basic to any public speaking class, or is covered by a year in Toastmasters or a similar organization. However, if you’re doing instructional videos, you can improve your product — your presentation–not only by taking courses or training but also by paying attention to what you’re doing, being prepared, and simply working at being better.
Posted on December 29th, 2016 No comments
Just before Christmas, on Dec. 22, 2016, TechJoint (TJ) published a youtube video titled “5 Amazing 3d Printers For Beginners”. It was nothing but a compendium of promo videos from Kickstarter campaigns with no original content, review, or comment.
Still, I was a bit surprised by some of their choices. Let’s take a closer look.
OLO 3D SLA Printer
First up, OLO. The OLO was intended to be a mini SLA printer powered by your cell phone. I had looked at it and decided to stay away. The original Olo 3d Printer video and campaign have been criticized because
- it glosses over the fact that your phone will be tied up for hours by a print
- it shows alleged light-sensitive resins in clear plastic bottles, which is seen as deceptive
- it claims cost-equality with FDM printers, yet the resin is far more expensive than filament
- the fundraising goals have been seen as far too low for product development
The printer has been panned by Maker’s Muse, KickScammed, Quora, and elsewhere (the Quora discussion in particular has considerable detail) but apparently is technically feasible and may eventually come to fruition. But don’t hold your breath — in the KS comments section, backers have been reduced to chatting about Mexican food.
101Hero 3D Delta Printer
101Hero’s campaigns on both Kickstarter and Indiegogo were well-fulfilled, with some 3700 backers. The unit is simple and cheap, made of injection-molded plastic The blue production model isn’t nearly as pretty as the white prototype shown in their campaign video, but it has started shipping (I have one working on the desk beside me).
The early round of deliveries suffered from failed stepper motors and missing parts; the company is focused on shipping and has been ignoring customer complaints (perhaps not the best of strategies) until shipping is completed. Lack of communication from the creator is also a constant complaint. The official Facebook group is static and unhelpful, but there is an active unofficial FB group for users.
Angus at Maker’s Muse backed the 101Hero but has not yet received it at the time I write this. I’d have thought that the company would take care to get a unit to an influential backer. Since I backed mine late through Indiegogo yet was among the first to receive one, I suspect that they are pushing retail sales to generate cashflow — not fair to backers, but not uncommon.
Kodama Trinus All-Metal 3D Cartesian Printer/Laser Engraver
Trinus set their standard as being a solid, all-metal, streamlined industrial design. Their polished campaign video was humorous and catchy, attracting over 3,000 backers and $1.6 million. The unit was well reviewed and backed by Maker’s Muse, which apparently attracted backers. The bare-bones printer was $299 with add-ons (heated bed, laser engraver, enclosure, LCD screen, filament pack) driving the price as high as $900 USD with shipping.
Like many KS campaigns, development was behind schedule, and shipping fell several months late. However, the company has started shipping with units to reach most backers in early 2017. Users and potential users have both an official forum and an active official FB group.
Minitoy’s approach was, like 101Hero, push-button simplicity. However, the Minitoy is specifically aimed at children and schools, and stresses safety (in that it prints only PLA). The video seems to focus on toy production. Early criticisms cited
- lack of a locking door,
- lack of ventilation,
- problems with filament loading
- lack of USB connection
The company has promised to find a solution to the door issue, but object that a lock would significantly increase costs. They’re considering sensors that would halt the print and retract the head if the door is opened during a print.
The product has had the usual holdups but may ship to their 600-odd backers in early 2017. Comments on the KS site are of the “Please show some videos of real prints?” and “When are you going to ship?” variety. Their FB group, like that of the 101Hero, has little of value to users, and presently has few user/backer comments.
As for the iBox Nano, apparently it quietly disappeared.
It seems odd that TJ should recommend for beginners at least three printers that have significant issues. OLO and iBox seem to be non-starters. Minitoy is working through their issues and plans to ship in 2017. 101Hero has yet to address their lack of customer service, but has begun shipping (mostly) working printers. The most expensive of the lot, the Kodama Trinus, is shipping now, with most users due to receive their units in early 2017.
- 5 Tips for Better Instructional Videos
- The 101Hero 3D Printer – or is it 101Villain?
- Kodama Trinus 3D Printer
Posted on December 28th, 2016 No comments
A couple of nice companies have provided free sample filaments for me to play with. Now that I have at least a vague idea how to set up my 101Hero 3D printer so I get mostly decent results, it’s time to look at some of the more exotic and interesting of these samples. First up: a phosphorescent filament.
Testing RepRap Glow-in-the-Dark Green Filament
Typical projects for glow-in-the-dark prints include stars and other galactic subjects; these filaments are also popular for Hallowe’en decorations. The more dense the print, the brighter the glow, it seems, so thick walls and heavy infill are recommended. I had a three metre sample of RepRap’s glow-in-the-dark green PLA so I wanted a small project.
For several reasons, I chose the Planet Ornament series by Microsoftstore from Thingiverse.
First, they’re a suitable subject.
Second, they appear to have enough mass to give a bright glow.
Third, I could print two of them from the sample filament supplied by RepRap Warehouse.
They’ll be a good little gift item for grand-children (problem: I have three grandkids and can make only two ornaments).
The filament measured at five different spots with a digital caliper: 1.71mm, 1.72 mm, 1.73 mm, 1.71 mm, 1.74 mm. Using the “throw away the extremes and average the remaining three” method gives an average of about 1.725. Is that really important? In Cura 15.02.1 I left the filament set to 1.75 and the flow at 100% because changing those settings seems to have NO effect on the 101Hero.
The filament printed just fine with standard settings (layer height 0.2; shell/top/bottom thickness 1.2; fill 20% (but could be solid); print/retraction/travel speed 12 mm/s @ 200C.
Ah, But Does it Glow?
A few seconds in the sunlight to charge it up, then into the main bathroom (only room in the house without a window!) to test it out.
That was about 30 seconds in the sun, not even tipped up perpendicular to the sunlight, and enough glow to see and photograph. The glow lasted for quite a while, and the medallion seems to have recharged under the incandescent lighting above the bathroom vanity.
The RepRap glow-in-the-dark PLA printed easily, needed no special twiddling of settings, and did indeed glow in the dark. Is it worth paying $30 CAD plus shipping for a kilogram of this filament? Not entirely sure yet. Probably my grandkids will twist my arm a bit and persuade me to buy some.
- First impressions of the 101Hero 3D printer (not good!)
- Waiting for a Trinus 3D printer (it’s only a few months late!)
- Will the M3D Pro live up to expectations? Due in 2017.
- Hacking the 101Hero
Posted on December 28th, 2016 No comments
Although I haven’t had any luck at all with the failaments (deliberate misspelling) that came with the 101Hero, filaments from other companies have printed with no issues. RepRap Silver, Botfeeder Opaque Red, and RepRap Translucent White, the only ones I’ve tried so far, have done well. I had wanted to order samples from eSun, but it turned out that shipping costs were prohibitive.
Sample Filaments From Kind Suppliers
BotFeeder PLA, BotFeeder Canada, Ontario
- Opaque Red – a particularly bright red
- Transparent Natural – a clear filament, should make a pretty vase or window ornament
- Gold – a metallic
- Flex Natural – a flexible filament, not sure what to do with it
RepRap PLA, RepRap Warehouse, Edmonton, Alberta
- Glow-in-the-Dark Green
- Thermal Color-Changing
- Flex Blue
Each set of samples came in a single zip-lock bag. I separated them, and put each filament into its own sandwich bag, labelled with the supplier and type of filament. It’s dry in the Alberta winter so was not too concerned about desiccant. Nor was I particularly neat in my labeling, not being too obsessive about such things. In the future, however, I will print up a business-card sized label showing the manufacturer, supplier, color, recommended extrusion temperature, and whatever other information I can find about the filament. This will save me having to look it up every time I want to use a sample.
The box in which the 101Hero 3D printer was shipped is sturdy and turned out to be just the right size for storing filament, both spools and samples.
Guess I’m as organized as I’m going to get. Next step is to start testing some of the more exotic sample filaments. I think I’ll start with the glow-in-the-dark green. Oooh, I’m so excited!